Which Island Is Best For A Luxurious Beach Vacation–st. Kitts Or Nevis?

If I were to go on a vacation, which island would be better for me–I am interested in staying at a five-star resort and want nice beaches.
Random question about this– If somebody built a 5 Star Resort in Nevis in around 2020, would competition with the Four Seasons be tough–by then?

"We are specialized in providing information about beach vacations and holiday. All of our articles will be useful to those who are interested in beach vacation, and we will continue to add more as the need arises."